I know many pundits expect Ugueth Urbina to be dealt now that Troy Percival has signed with the Detroit Tigers. However, this Tigers fan isn't in too big a hurry to see Urbina leave. There are two reasons I prefer that U.U. staying with Detroit.
First, I really like the idea of having Urbina as a set-up man. Having Urbina pitch the eighth and Percival in the ninth is a huge upgrade over last year. It also makes it a seven inning game for whatever starter the Tigers run out on the hill. Faced with the prospect of pitching only seven innings should make all their starters a bit better. If the Tigers can land one more bullpen arm, or find one internally, starters might have to only go six innings. How is that not better?
The second reason I want Ugie to stay: Injuries. Percival's had more than a few lately. Even healthy, some question just how many innings the Tigers' new closer can provide. Having Urbina around is insurance. If Urbina is dealt, the Tigers are left hoping a thirty-five year old with a number of ailments can go an entire season. If Percival were to get hurt there wouldn't be another viable closer option. Which is precisely what happened when Urbina had to leave this year. That wasn't pretty.
It's great to add Percival to the staff, but keeping Urbina could make the bullpen a strength. Who would have imagined that in September?
As for Percival's acquistion itself, on a scale of 1-10, I give it a seven. His age and injury history make me a bit leery. I also have to wait to see what other moves result from this deal. If Percival's pal, Troy Glaus signs with the Tigers, then my rating would have to go up. Worst case scenario is that Percival does nothing, but only gets paid for two years. It's a risk, but not a long-term one.
For other opinions on the Tigers' newest addition check out these links:
Michael Rosenberg, Detroit Free Press
Tom Gage, Detroit News
ESPN.com
David Pinto, Baseball Musings
Dayn Perry, Fox Sports
No comments:
Post a Comment